Edited Sunday 7:45 AM: I just had one of those "oh no!" moments realizing I mislabeled the lip swatch colors. I have corrected the labeling errors and included three colors instead of two.
After more testing & swatching I have to say these new Velvet Gloss Pencils from NARS are an enigma to me. They're totally different than what I expected on the lips. Has anyone else experienced the same results? Maybe there is something with my natural lip tone and skin type causing them to change with my body chemistry? They apply on the lips a lot more vibrant than what I see in the tube or swatched on the hand. Here are lip swatches of Hopi (brownish peachy nude), Happy Days (bright peach) and New Lover (raspberry gold).
Hopi (brownish peach) in daylight:
Hopi at night:
New Lover (raspberry gold) swatched with 1/2 my lip in direct sunlight:
New Lover lip swatched at dusk: