This is a follow up on my Shu Uemura haul from last week to compare Seal Brown with my other brow products. I have dark brown/black hair with red highlights - but you can only see the reddish/brown if I am wearing a black shirt or if I'm in the sun, so just consider my hair black.
Brow products are usually too harsh, ashy or reddish for my hair color. I've been matched with all these shades from various makeovers and I am surprised that they all work, however Seal Brown works the best. It looks really light in the pot/swatch, but works really well for a soft natural dark brow.
Here it is compared to Laura Mercier Soft, Chanel Blonde & Chanel Soft Brown with different views/backgrounds and then swatches.
* Note that Bobbi Brown Mahogany Ink is a gel liner, not a brow product, it's simply swatched so you can gauge how soft the other brow product colors are.